• NEWS
    • Agencies
    • Brand Marketing
    • Creativity
    • Digital
    • Programmatic
    • TV / Video
    • FEATURED
    • Challenger Brands
    • Inside the Brand
    • Ad of the Day
    • CES
    • Sponsored
  • EVENTS
    • FEATURED
      • Elevate AI 2019
      • March 21, 2019
        New York
    • COMING SOON
    • Adweek Media All-Stars
    • Fastest-Growing Agencies
    • View All Events
  • WEBINARS
    • FEATURED
      • You’re Measuring Influencer Marketing Wrong
      • Tues., March 5, 2019
        1 PM EST
    • COMING SOON
    • CMO Tenure Data Is the Secret to Agency Business Development
    • The Definitive Approach to Advanced Media Measurement
    • View All Webinars
  • CONNECT
    • Media Kit
    • Editorial Calendar
    • Agency Memberships
    • Group Subscriptions
    • Newsletters
    • Contact Us
    • ADVERTISE WITH US
    • Brand Awareness
    • Thought Leadership
    • Lead Generation
    • ADWEEK NETWORK
    • AgencySpy
    • MarketerMoves​
    • Social Pro Daily​
    • TVNewser
    • TVSpy
  • ADWEEK JOBS
    • Find a Job
    • Post a Job
    • CURRENT OFFER
    • Unlimited Job Postings
My Account Log Out Sign In Subscribe

Digital

Nuns Among Shareholders Asking Amazon Not to Trade Privacy for Profit

Resolution calls for rights advocates to vet Rekognition

By Lisa Lacy
|
January 17, 2019
The shareholders are concerned about abuses of facial recognition technology by government agencies.
Amazon
Share
By Lisa Lacy
|
January 17, 2019
Share

A group of nuns joining forces to take on an all-powerful tech company sounds like the plot of Sister Act 3, but it actually happened in Brooklyn—sort of.

Amazon shareholders representing more than $1.3 billion in assets filed a resolution Thursday asking the company to stop selling its facial-recognition technology, Rekognition, to government agencies until the board of directors consults with rights advocates. Those shareholders include a religious organization, the Sisters of St. Joseph of Brentwood, which filed the resolution.

Their proposal says shareholders are concerned Rekognition “poses risk to civil and human rights and shareholder value.” As a result, it recommends the Amazon board work with advocates to evaluate the extent to which Rekognition may violate privacy or civil rights, particularly among people of color, and how Amazon plans to mitigate that risk as well as the extent to which Rekognition may be sold to repressive governments.

The Sisters of St. Joseph is part of a nonprofit group of Roman Catholic institutional investors called the Tri-State Coalition for Responsible Investment.

The use of facial recognition is increasing in public spaces, but there are few laws regulating it, which is in part why there is rising concern over privacy and security. In fact, this is just the latest in a long line of requests, including one from the American Civil Liberties Union, that Congress intervene after Rekognition incorrectly matched 28 members of Congress with mugshots—and those elected officials were disproportionately people of color.

“We filed this proposal because we are concerned that Amazon has pitched facial recognition technology to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and piloted its Rekognition with police departments, without fully assessing potential human rights impacts,” Sister Patricia Mahoney said in a statement.

Emails obtained by the ACLU through a Freedom of Information Act request show Amazon has pitched government agencies, and Rekognition has been used by law enforcement in Oregon and Florida.

“The fact that Amazon’s shareholders felt compelled to take this up to the company’s board of directors should be a wake-up call to Amazon’s leadership to take concerns around face surveillance seriously,” the ACLU said in a statement. “It shouldn’t take a board or shareholder intervention for the company to do right by immigrants, people of color, religious minorities, protesters and activists who are disproportionately harmed by such new surveillance technologies.”

The shareholders also point out Rekognition contradicts Amazon’s opposition to facilitating surveillance, and shareholders have little evidence it is “effectively restricting the use of Rekognition to protect privacy and civil rights.”

In a statement, Mary Beth Gallagher, executive director of the Tri-State Coalition for Responsible Investment, pointed to the potential for targeted surveillance and rights abuses.

“Our proposal encourages Amazon to prohibit future sales of its Rekognition software to government agencies until the company has fully evaluated actual and potential human rights impacts of this technology,” she said.

Share
https://adweek.it/2RDuQCs
Lisa Lacy

Lisa Lacy

@lisalacy
Lisa Lacy is a tech reporter for Adweek.
Adweek Adweek Adweek

Popular Now

  • 1
    Hate Doing Laundry? No Sweat. Tide Just Announced It’ll Do It for You
  • 2
    Any Brand Not Marketing in the Esports World Is Already Behind the Curve
  • 3
    You Can Experience Westeros at SXSW This Year With HBO and Giant Spoon’s Immersive Game of...
  • 4
    NBCUniversal Entertainment Places Media Planning and Buying Business in Review
  • 5
    Why Budweiser Saved a Super Bowl Spot Starring Charlize Theron for the Oscars

Featured Jobs

Account Strategist
Warehouse Twenty One, Inc.
Cheyenne, Wyoming
New Business Sales Executive
Thomson Reuters
New York, New York
Editorial Director
UCLA
LOS ANGELES, California
Anchor/Producer/Multi-Media Journalist
WENY TV
Horseheads, New York
Social Media Specialist
Leatherman
Portland, Oregon
See More Jobs

EDITOR'S PICKS

Brand Marketing

Karl Lagerfeld, Chanel's Iconic Creative Director, Was the Brand's 'Modern Era Personified'

by Diana Pearl

Brand Marketing

Hate Doing Laundry? No Sweat. Tide Just Announced It'll Do It for You

by Robert Klara

AdFreak

Thanks to Ancestry, Six Strangers Learn How They're Connected Via the Underground Railroad

by Shannon Miller

SXSW

Michelob Ultra and the Big Quiet Want to Soothe Your SXSW With a Sunset Meditation

by Kristina Monllos

SXSW

You Can Experience Westeros at SXSW This Year With HBO and Giant Spoon's Immersive Game of Thrones Activation

by Kristina Monllos

Brand Marketing

Why Budweiser Saved a Super Bowl Spot Starring Charlize Theron for the Oscars

by Kristina Monllos

Brand Marketing

Burberry Apologizes for Sending Hoodie With Strings Resembling a Noose Down the Runway

by Katie Richards

Ad of the Day

Are Sizzle Reels a Complete Waste of Everyone's Time? The Atlantic and Errol Morris Say Yes

by David Griner
View Latest News >
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • Media Kit
    • Editorial Calendar
    • Sponsor Content
    • Jobs
  • Subscriptions
    • Subscription Options
    • Digital App
    • Newsletters
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Customer Service
  • Awards / Honors / Events
    • Awards and Honors
    • Adweek Events
    • Webinars
    • On-Demand Webinars
    • Trophies / Awards / Seals
  • Publications
    • Adweek Network
    • RSS
    • Backissues
    • Reprints / E-Prints
  • © 2019 Adweek, LLC. - All Rights Reserved
  • About Adweek
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy