Feeling Seen Sells: Etsy Makes Meaning the Message

In our latest Ad Critic column, Bill Imada reviews Etsy's holiday campaign.

As a small business owner who’s been at it for more than three decades, I see Etsy’s holiday campaign as a smart reminder of what independent brands can uniquely win on—meaning and personalization, not just merchandise. 

The campaign is emotionally grounded and strategically consistent with Etsy’s “I get you/feel seen” platform. In a season where big-box and marketplaces compete on volume, deals, and speed, Etsy is choosing the lane that small businesses have always owned: personal relevance.

What stood out to me—especially through a multicultural and multigenerational lens—is how naturally the diversity shows up across the three spots. It isn’t performative or forced.

UNLOCK FULL ACCESS

Subscribe and get full access to the news, insights, and expertise that keep industry professionals ahead of the curve.

VIEW ALL SUBSCRIPTION OPTIONS
Headshot of Bill Imada

Bill Imada

Bill Imada is co-founder, chairman, and chief connectivity officer of IW Group.