the ad critiques are in

Superadfreakgrass_3Which of BBDO’s FedEx spots did David Lubars prefer? (The answer might surprise you.) How did the Budweiser commercials go down at Jim Ferguson’s Super Bowl party? (Better than the beer itself, hopefully.) Do you agree with Chris Wall that, overall, there were lots of good ads last night, but not many great ones? Head over to, where you can post your critiques next to those of 20 guest bloggers who’ve been writing about more than 40 Super Bowl ads. The critiques are cross-reference by ad and by writer, so you can easily find who said what—and then flame them. [We’re working on SuperAdFreak today mostly, so posts here will be few.]

—Posted by Tim Nudd