EXCLUSIVE: How The Chernin Group’s Content-to-Commerce Bet Came Crashing Down

At Food52, Hodinkee, and The Pro’s Closet, the private equity firm’s strategy showed its faults. Then came the closures.

In October 2024, after three rounds of layoffs and a desperate going-out-of-business sale, The Pro’s Closet finally shut its doors. 

The used-bike marketplace, once a pandemic darling, had grown from a garage eBay hustle into a venture-backed business that brought in around $75 million in annual revenue in 2022, according to three people familiar with its finances. But its final years were marked by shrinking sales, steep losses, and the fallout from its ill-fated acquisition of a retail media brand. 

At the same time, a similar story was unfolding elsewhere. Hodinkee, once the most influential watch publication on the web, had acquired and quickly jettisoned a commerce business, and was then sold off in pieces.

UNLOCK FULL ACCESS

Subscribe and get full access to the news, insights, and expertise that keep industry professionals ahead of the curve.

VIEW ALL SUBSCRIPTION OPTIONS
Mark_Stenberg

Mark Stenberg

Mark Stenberg is ADWEEK's senior media reporter.