The Anne Stuart story has become one of our most popular items this month, sparking conversations across the book-lovin’ blogosphere. It also prompted novelist Deborath Smith (right), herself a NYT bestselling author, to write in with a few words of support for her colleague. “Anne may sound wishy-washy to you,” Smith emails, “but look, it’s a freakin’ miracle her book made the NYT list given the general screw-ups, apathy, bad planning and all-around incompetency of the NY pub houses. She made that list because she has slogged her way through numerous disasters and built a readership; not because Harlequin suddenly decided to do something sweet for her.”
“So yes, she can be thrilled and make nice with Harlequin today while still expressing real caution and cynicism,” Smith adds. “Harlequin didn’t make her career for her; no publisher did. Anne succeeded on her own while surviving an enormous amount of publisher bungling that makes it, as I said, a miracle that any author rises out of the shadows to find an audience.” Is the path to publishing success as dimly lit as Smith describes it? Or do authors succeed thanks to their publishers, rather than despite them? Tell us your stories…