Brands That Offer Lifetime Guarantees | Adweek Brands That Offer Lifetime Guarantees | Adweek
Advertisement

For Some Retail Brands, Lifetime Guarantees Never Went Out of Fashion

No expiration, no questions asked

Even if you’re up on your legal reading, it’s likely that you missed the case of Roy L. Pearson v. Soo Chung, et al. In 2007, Washington, D.C., resident Roy Pearson hauled a local store called Custom Cleaners to court over a bungled trouser alteration that cost $10.50. “Never before in recorded history have a group of defendants engaged in such misleading and unfair business practices,” declared Pearson, who sought $54 million in damages. 

Photo: Winni Wintermeyer

His grounds? A “Satisfaction Guaranteed” sign that hung inside the store.

Granted, that’s an extreme example of an unhappy customer. But Pearson and consumers like him are a great example of why most brands steer clear of making satisfaction guarantees. Sure, plenty of retailers will take an item back—unused, with store receipt, and within 30 to 90 days of purchase; limited warrantees such as that are, in fact, typical. But companies that hold themselves to the gold standard, promising to make customers happy no matter what, are rare, notes Scott Davis, chief growth officer for the brand consultancy Prophet. “One hundred percent guarantees—no expiration, no questions asked—are the stuff of legend,” he says.

But, as it turns out, they’re still with us. Despite the rise of the throwaway culture and disposable goods (everything from clothing and technology to plastic containers for leftovers), there are those brands that still make products for keeps, and guarantee them. [To see Adweek's big list of forever brands, click here.] Among them, such venerable retailers that are famous for such policies, including L.L. Bean, The North Face, Craftsman and Lands’ End. Add to those, though, a healthy number of smaller, newer brands, among them umbrella maker Davek (founded 2005), Darn Tough socks (2004) and Bogs footwear (2002). All these companies promise total customer satisfaction, as do specialty brands like Polar Bottles, Briggs & Riley luggage and Oxo household utensils.

There is a reason so many companies are still doing it. The satisfaction guarantee, experts point out, generates customer loyalty and positive word of mouth for a brand. That said, it also offers an equal share of hassles and risks. As customer service consultant Micah Solomon puts it, “The satisfaction guarantee is a relative rarity, but with the power of social media, it can become a marketing opportunity.” Then again, he adds, “maybe it’s also marketing to people who want to screw you.”

Ric Cabot, for one, isn’t worried. As founder of the hosiery brand Darn Tough, Cabot has had an unconditional lifetime guarantee in place from the day he powered up his looms in Vermont. Darn Tough socks are impervious to holes, Cabot promises—and if they ever do get them, he’ll replace the item. (To quote the company policy: “No strings. No conditions. For life.”) 

Decked out in L.L. Bean, 1941
Photo: George Strock/Time Life Pictures/Getty Images

“We make the product, and that’s the difference,” says Cabot, who explains that the fad of fast fashion, coupled with offshore manufacturing, have conspired to kill off the guarantees that were once a given with consumer brands. “There are segments of the market that don’t expect—or it’s never occurred to them—that something should last more than 30 or 90 days,” he says. “In the race to outsource, to get new product into people’s hands, brands have stopped talking about guarantees because they don’t need to talk about it.”

So why does Cabot? “What I learned in advertising school is that the message is the medium,” he relates. With all of Darn Tough’s packaging and retail displays bearing the brand’s satisfaction pledge, Cabot believes his customers “empathize” with him simply for having the guts to offer one. “Customers think, my goodness, they stand behind their product, and they’re not a Fortune 500 company? It’s got to be good,” he says.

David Cook, marketing director for the Portland, Ore.-based Bogs, tells a similar story. While satisfaction guarantees tend to be the domain of long-established merchants, Cook believes the pledge has given his young company a competitive edge. “Because we’re a relatively new brand, it helps to instill trust in consumers,” he says. A promise of satisfaction removes the risk from a purchase, Cook says, meaning “people have peace of mind, and that’s influenced the perception of the company. It’s been a huge thing for us.”

Adds Prophet’s Davis: “These promises engender brand loyalty even among consumers who don’t actually take advantage of them. Just knowing that the company stands behind its products speaks volumes.”

In some cases—notably the heritage brands that have had guarantees in place for generations—those volumes have already been recorded and have turned into expectations among the public. Nordstrom, for example, doesn’t boast about having retail’s most permissive return policy because it is desperate to win customers. It’s because the store’s affluent, longtime customers expect nothing less.

Continue to next page →

Advertisement

Advertisement