Cover Battle: Scene or Vanity Fair

Welcome back to another edition of FishbowlNY’s weekly Cover Battle. This round features Scene versus Vanity Fair. Scene went all in with Joe Jonas because apparently it’s still 2008.

Scene’s competition, Vanity Fair, features Scarlett Johansson doing something really weird with her face. What the hell is going on there? Seriously, no one ever makes that face, do they? Maybe she had food poisoning.

So readers, which cover is better? You can vote, comment, or do both.