Creative > Ad of the Day

Ad of the Day

Milwaukee Police "Walking"

Brand: Milwaukee Police
Agency: Cramer-Krasselt
Review Date: August 06, 2009

The only sounds are the footsteps of a lone woman as she walks down the darkest dark alley you've ever seen. Surely something bad is going to happen. But it doesn't, which is the point of this offbeat commercial (via Cramer-Krasselt, Milwaukee) for Milwaukee's police department. After one onscreen super has given the datum "2,945 fewer crime victims in Milwaukee last year," another one comments on the non-event we've just witnessed: "In some jobs, success is measured by what doesn't happen." Quite true. And viewers will surely take away the impression that Milwaukee's police force must be doing something right. It's less obvious that the spot will be effective in drumming up recruits for the force. One can easily draw the conclusion that being a police officer is a thankless task, since the woman isn't going to thank a cop for the fact she didn't get mugged in this alley. The spot leads one to the quite accurate thought that good policing is something people will take for granted. After all, people notice danger; they don't notice the absence of danger. The 2,945 non-crime-victims cited in the spot don't think of themselves as people who would have been victims were it not for the police department's good work. Of course, it's not as though a Milwaukee police officer is like the Maytag repairman, sitting around waiting for mishaps that never happen. But the spot doesn't build a powerful emotional appeal around the profession, even while making an intellectual case for its civic usefulness. On the plus side, the spot will appeal more strongly to people who'd like to be civil servants of a sort than to those who imagine themselves winning glory in shootouts with bad guys. So, you could say the spot will tend to cull out the less desirable kind of would-be applicants while attracting the more responsible types. And it should help to promote civilian assistance to the police department, which is another aim of this branding campaign. --Mark Dolliver

View Credits

Overall rating:
(2.6 ) Good

35 Comments
  • 1. justsomeone comments:
    August 30, 2009

    You keep watching the ad. These days, that's saying something.


  • 2. Goldoneshow comments:
    August 20, 2009

    Poorly written. Out of date look. Overall, meh. Plus with the mayor getting clocked, not great timing.


  • 3. A Huge Lie comments:
    August 16, 2009

    08/16/2009 "Milwaukee mayor wounded after being hit with pipe." This spot is complete nonsense.


  • 4. Ed comments:
    August 15, 2009

    Great.Unexpected. Very clever and simple. God bless the agency team and client.


  • 5. LOL comments:
    August 10, 2009

    There are twelve creatives listed in the credits for this "locked off" camera spot. Come on!


  • 6. Milvaukee comments:
    August 10, 2009

    Cops may like it, but the citizens know that this is factually untrue and something no intelligent woman would do. Clearly the person portrayed in this spot would have been drunk in real life.


  • 7. Dumb comments:
    August 10, 2009

    Great, actually just good, creative has a story and a conceptual twist. This is an executed strategy not a television idea. It is something kids in school think up and then the professors push them beyond. Good start. Poor finish.


  • 8. JD comments:
    August 09, 2009

    Not too bad. Could have done without the '2984 less victims' bit- took me out of the commercial and made me wonder how they came up with that number. The last shot says enough because everyone watching will expect her to get mugged. No need to beat people over the head with it.


  • 9. brianf comments:
    August 08, 2009

    cool


  • 10. mh comments:
    August 08, 2009

    simple...nice


  • 11. mrk comments:
    August 08, 2009

    I'd say the ad is average and plays on the paranoia of women. But a response to "Huh?" Seriously, that is your comment. It is people like you - who take everything so literal - that drive advertising people insane. Expand your mind just a tad bit more and you just might get it.


  • 12. WAKEFORESTINTN comments:
    August 07, 2009

    I love this ad too!!!


  • 13. UGADAWGS comments:
    August 07, 2009

    I love this ad!!!


  • 14. Huh? comments:
    August 07, 2009

    Danger lurks around every corner, not down every alley.


  • 15. Mark Drossman comments:
    August 07, 2009

    Reminds me of a commercial when I was a kid: A guy is walking down a dark alley way, towards the camera. A gang of boys suddenly appears behind him. The guy gets nervous as the kids catch up to him. Camera reveals they are Boy Scouts as they pass him. His relief is palpable.


  • 16. Bilbo comments:
    August 06, 2009

    Apparently someone got let go by CK or was let go and decided to post under 15 different names on here. It's a simple idea, well-enough produced...but I wouldn't book a room at Cannes.


  • 17. su comments:
    August 06, 2009

    very good message


  • 18. ct comments:
    August 06, 2009

    for those of you who dislike this - do you remember that each project is about your audience and client... rather than your own ego? its not the most brilliant ad ever made - but surely ck is aware of that. its for the police department and the mainstream public - c'mon.


  • 19. C-K WI comments:
    August 06, 2009

    Stop trying to turn the honest comments here around. Clearly if this was to "speak to the public" you should not have sent it to Adweek. It is simple though. It is simply bad.


  • 20. ELGATO comments:
    August 06, 2009

    It made the point. It did the job. Get your egos back on a leash, this was created to speak to the public -not to impress industry peers.


  • 21. Shamwow comments:
    August 06, 2009

    C-K did you have the summer interns work on this one. WOW


  • 22. Brian comments:
    August 06, 2009

    Pretty sophmoric. Sad; C-K was once a great shop. What's happened?


  • 23. me comments:
    August 06, 2009

    Nice and simple. By the way, the amount of haters on this site is off the charts.


  • 24. College comments:
    August 06, 2009

    I had an idea like this when I was in school. Bush league.


  • 25. Please comments:
    August 06, 2009

    It's so lame.


  • 26. TLP comments:
    August 06, 2009

    It's simple and to the point. Not sure what these other posters were expecting - Uma Thurman to be walking down the alley for the ad to really make a impact?? Get out of here! The point is well made. Great job.


  • 27. Ville comments:
    August 06, 2009

    Isn't this the same group of hacks that did "Welcome to sausage town?"


  • 28. What? comments:
    August 06, 2009

    A one off for a free client. This group doesn't even know how to do 360 work, much less big television.


  • 29. LOL comments:
    August 06, 2009

    You always have to wonder why agencies like this never hire talent. Get a great CD or EXCD and you will get great work. Not this bull.


  • 30. Boring comments:
    August 06, 2009

    Simply stupid.


  • 31. DK comments:
    August 06, 2009

    The idea is OK. But with the chance to do what is clearly a pro bono assignment - THAT'S what you go with?! Wouldn't say it's an opportunity wasted, but wouldn't say they made the most of it either. And for that reason...two stars.http://www.adweek.com/aw/creative/ad-of-the-day/article_display.jsp?creativeId=270241#


  • 32. meyerheim comments:
    August 06, 2009

    I like it. Makes you follow the ad to the end. Local docal seems to like himself very much.


  • 33. quoinguy comments:
    August 06, 2009

    Clean concept cuts through the noise. Local docal sound like a douche.


  • 34. jim schmidt comments:
    August 06, 2009

    nice and simple way to make the point.


  • 35. Local docal comments:
    August 05, 2009

    LMAO!!! Strategically not a bad idea. Executionally, come on. Did you need to put the entire creative department on the credits? I mean seriously how pathetic is this mid-west offshoot, well, pretty pathetic.


Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
*Author:
*Rate This Ad: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
The opinions expressed in comments are those of the individual poster. They do not necessarily reflect the views of Adweek or Nielsen Business Media. Comments of a promotional nature or comments that are off-topic or otherwise inappropriate may be removed.





Our ProductsOur Products

ADWEEK'S CREATIVE NEWSLETTER

A weekly newsletter focusing on the creative community: New campaigns, personnel moves and much more.

SUBSCRIBE

Stay connected to what's happening in the advertising industry with delivery of the print edition and complete online access.




Adweek Advertising Home | Advertising Industry News | Creative TV Advertising | Advertising Industry Community | Video Advertising | Advertising Data Center | Advertising Special Reports | Advertising Careers | Advertising Products | Advertising About Us | Advertising Business Statements | Advertising Contact Us | Advertising Opportunities | Ad Licensing | Advertiser FAQ | Advertising Magazine Subscriptions | Advertising News RSS | Online Ad Site Map | Mobile

© 2010 Adweek. All rights reserved. Terms of Use  |   Privacy Policy