ADWEEK WEB
Creative > News
SaveE-mailPrintMost PopularRSSReprints

Page 1 of 2


Barbara Lippert Critiques 'Art & Copy'

One Club film offers insightful on-camera interviews but falls short on context

July 8, 2009

- Barbara Lippert


adweek/photos/stylus/97196-LeeClow.jpg

In the film, Lee Clow and other ad luminaries relate fascinating tales from the front.

Dan Wieden came up with perhaps the most famous advertising tagline of the late 20th century, "Just do it" for Nike, after hearing serial killer Gary Gilmore's last words before facing a firing squad in Utah. "Let's do it," Gilmore said, famously.

"I liked the 'do it'" part, Wieden says, smiling.

That's the most intriguing thing I learned from Art & Copy, the often delightful and beautifully shot documentary commissioned by The One Club and opening in theaters on Aug. 21.

Directed by Doug Pray and taken from "an original concept by Gregory Beauchamp and Kirk Souder," the 86-minute film is chockablock with remarkable on-camera interviews with ad luminaries, many of them members of The One Club Hall of Fame.

It's particularly moving to see Hal Riney, who died not long after he was interviewed, sounding robust as he speaks in his trademark soothing cadences, opening up about his father "going to the pokey for writing bad checks." As a result, he admits that perhaps, "I let advertising be the avenue to express some of the things that I didn't experience in my life."

Wow. Think about that! If Riney's father had been a more upstanding citizen, perhaps "Morning Again in America" never would have been made, and Ronald Reagan would have been a one-term president!

Actually, advertising greats and their daddy issues could have been a whole separate documentary, given how many times the interviewees mention the need to prove something to their fathers.

Lee Clow -- who offers some fascinating, little-known factoids about the making (and almost pre-Super Bowl suppression) of Apple's "1984" -- talks honestly about the need to prove his worth to his dad and/or Jay Chiat.

But that's my quibble with this film -- it's elicited some amazing sound bites from ad greats, but doesn't provide any editorial context or interpretation. Like the ad industry itself, the documentary suffers from an infrastructure problem.

Perhaps that's the underside of being commissioned by The One Club -- there's no attempt to follow up. Rather, it's more like a survey course that keeps moving around, both in time and geography. In fairness, this allows the film to cover a lot of ground (and in doing so, offers the most complete history of West Coast advertising yet.) So it's busting with great stuff. But as a journalist, my natural instinct would be to take this gripping material, some of it revealed for the first time from rarely seen but enormously respected sources like Jim Durfee and Cliff Freeman, and set up arguments and counterarguments and draw conclusions.

Instead of building a narrative, the filmmakers chose to hang the talking-head interviews and footage of classic commercials on some weird visual scaffolding. We get a profile of a third-generation guy who puts up billboards and an interview with some French dude about satellites. These allow for some arty cinematic interludes, but don't advance the main story. (Here again, it might have been interesting to see the billboard ad from initial idea through production.)



Barbara Lippert Critiques 'Art & Copy'

One Club film offers insightful on-camera interviews but falls short on context

July 8, 2009

- Barbara Lippert


adweek/photos/stylus/97196-LeeClow.jpg

In the film, Lee Clow and other ad luminaries relate fascinating tales from the front.

Dan Wieden came up with perhaps the most famous advertising tagline of the late 20th century, "Just do it" for Nike, after hearing serial killer Gary Gilmore's last words before facing a firing squad in Utah. "Let's do it," Gilmore said, famously.

"I liked the 'do it'" part, Wieden says, smiling.

That's the most intriguing thing I learned from Art & Copy, the often delightful and beautifully shot documentary commissioned by The One Club and opening in theaters on Aug. 21.

Directed by Doug Pray and taken from "an original concept by Gregory Beauchamp and Kirk Souder," the 86-minute film is chockablock with remarkable on-camera interviews with ad luminaries, many of them members of The One Club Hall of Fame.

It's particularly moving to see Hal Riney, who died not long after he was interviewed, sounding robust as he speaks in his trademark soothing cadences, opening up about his father "going to the pokey for writing bad checks." As a result, he admits that perhaps, "I let advertising be the avenue to express some of the things that I didn't experience in my life."

Wow. Think about that! If Riney's father had been a more upstanding citizen, perhaps "Morning Again in America" never would have been made, and Ronald Reagan would have been a one-term president!

Actually, advertising greats and their daddy issues could have been a whole separate documentary, given how many times the interviewees mention the need to prove something to their fathers.

Lee Clow -- who offers some fascinating, little-known factoids about the making (and almost pre-Super Bowl suppression) of Apple's "1984" -- talks honestly about the need to prove his worth to his dad and/or Jay Chiat.

But that's my quibble with this film -- it's elicited some amazing sound bites from ad greats, but doesn't provide any editorial context or interpretation. Like the ad industry itself, the documentary suffers from an infrastructure problem.

Perhaps that's the underside of being commissioned by The One Club -- there's no attempt to follow up. Rather, it's more like a survey course that keeps moving around, both in time and geography. In fairness, this allows the film to cover a lot of ground (and in doing so, offers the most complete history of West Coast advertising yet.) So it's busting with great stuff. But as a journalist, my natural instinct would be to take this gripping material, some of it revealed for the first time from rarely seen but enormously respected sources like Jim Durfee and Cliff Freeman, and set up arguments and counterarguments and draw conclusions.

Instead of building a narrative, the filmmakers chose to hang the talking-head interviews and footage of classic commercials on some weird visual scaffolding. We get a profile of a third-generation guy who puts up billboards and an interview with some French dude about satellites. These allow for some arty cinematic interludes, but don't advance the main story. (Here again, it might have been interesting to see the billboard ad from initial idea through production.)



But among the seldom-interviewed folks, we get time with Phyllis K. Robinson, an original DDBer, who held the antique but important title of "copy chief." It's a delight to see her -- she radiates intelligence and grace, and hardly looks different today from the old photo to which she points and says, "That's me, in the year I smoked." In recalling the formation of the agency, where Bill Bernbach revolutionized the business by putting copywriters and art directors together, rather than having art come as an illustrative afterthought to the text, she says modestly: "We had no sense of how big and important a move this was."

That's in sharp contrast to the always-amusing George Lois, who gets a lot of face time, because with every impassioned word he utters, he jumps off the screen.
 
Mary Wells is here too, and reveals that her parents pushed her into the theater. Her knack for knowing "what turns people on" and her theatrical sense led her into advertising. "I've had a big life," she says. "I have the energy. I don't get tired, maybe because I'm not afraid. I think fear is a powerful depressant."

What's interesting for insiders is to see how stars of the contemporary ad scene appear far less excited than the old timers. "It's a business of rejection," Jeff Goodby says. "Things get killed all the time. . . . The process can take a year, and it's very stressful and depressing to have those ideas killed. So there has to be a nurturing environment, so that people can get themselves up off the floor and do it again." 
 
In the end, I actually learned a lot. Art & Copy provides the definitive inside stories on campaigns ranging from "Think small" to "Got milk?"

Think of it more as a smart survey course of the last 50 years of advertising, and as such should be screened by media students everywhere.


Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author:
* Comment:
 
The opinions expressed in comments are those of the individual poster. They do not necessarily reflect the views of Adweek or Nielsen Business Media. Attacks of a personal nature and comments that are otherwise inappropriate may be removed.

Other Creative News

ACURA

An Inside Look at Acura

March 16, 2010

Acura's latest high-profile campaign offers glimpses of the mechanical soul that drives its machines. Tagged "The most innovative thinking you'll find, you'll find in an Acura," the work is an ambitious grab for sales at a time when luxury brands are wheezing under a lingering recession and competitors like BMW and Mercedes-Benz keep a firm lock on the performance car segment. A strict focus on literal nuts-and-bolts components represents a new tack. Read Full Article



Our ProductsOur Products

ADWEEK'S CREATIVE NEWSLETTER

A weekly newsletter focusing on the creative community: New campaigns, personnel moves and much more.

SUBSCRIBE

Stay connected to what's happening in the advertising industry with delivery of the print edition and complete online access.

More VideosVideo

Bud Light gives man the ability to breath fire with disatrous results.; bud light; DDB; fire; A man finds a car grille under his sheets.; Venables Bell; audi; godfather; super bowl; People nod off before being revived by having a Diet Pepsi Max.; BBDO; Chris Kattan; Diet Pepsi; Salesmen must double his sales so turns to salesgenie.com; Indian; mint; salesgenie; super bowl 2008; Men find ways to entertain themselves at a wine and cheese party.; bud light; cheese; DDB; super bowl; wine; Athletes undergo intense training before getting new shoe.; Eric Ogbogu; new prototype; under armour; Animals and people scream as a car almost hits a squirrel.; bridgestone; richards group; scream; squirrel; Kina sings "Message from Your Heart" as part of Doritos "Crash the Super Bowl" promotion.; doritos; Goodby; kina; super bowl 2008; People leave Prudential footprints in their wake.; footprints; insurance; prudential; Video player for AW Creative index and related pages. http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid1329217856http://www.brightcove.com/channel.jsp?channel=1126101268




Adweek Advertising Home | Advertising Industry News | Creative TV Advertising | Advertising Industry Community | Video Advertising | Advertising Data Center | Advertising Special Reports | Advertising Careers | Advertising Products | Advertising About Us | Advertising Business Statements | Advertising Contact Us | Advertising Opportunities | Ad Licensing | Advertiser FAQ | Advertising Magazine Subscriptions | Advertising News RSS | Online Ad Site Map

© 2010 Adweek. All rights reserved. Terms of Use  |   Privacy Policy