Creative > Critique By Barbara Lippert

Page 1 of 2


Making Mommy Dearest Look Good

A pair of celeb-reality shows takes motherhood to new lows

Barbara Lippert: Adweek Columnist

June 4, 2008

-By Barbara Lippert


adweek/photos/stylus/28217-DeniseRichardsL.jpg

Is Denise Richards 'keeping it real' on her new E! series?

CLICK HERE FOR BARBARA LIPPERT'S PODCAST.

One's an unstoppable momager, traversing Long Island in her custom-upholstered Range Rover, always on the phone. The other's obsessed with pigs and big "dicks," as she says several times on camera, while talking about the loves of her life.

OK, so it's no revelation that the ever-growing "celeb-reality" genre is proof that the end of days is upon us. Granted, the shows are lower than low, but at least the cheesy B- and D-listers who've starred in previous versions knew they were out of career options and chose the nasty self-sploitation instead.

Whereas what's maddening about Living Lohan and Denise Richards: It's Complicated, two shows launched recently as part of E's "Summer Funplex," is that both Mama Bear Dina and farm girl Denise claim they are participating to disprove the tabloids that continue to "trash" them and prove that their lives are, as Richards puts it, "all about family." And as Dina Lohan says, "I want people to know we're, like, normal."

And with that, these two cable programs establish that the new definition of insanity is doing a reality show to prove just how "like, normal" you are. The Lohan show is totally odious, in a depths of hell way that would suggest Dina's head might explode while she becomes possessed with the voice of Hulk Hogan. On the other hand, poor Denise Richards' show is not so much odious as odoriferous -- there's no poop at all, in the celebrity sense, just in the actual pig droppings sense, and there's a ton of that.

Before I saw her show, I actually felt sorry for her. You'd think being married to and then going through a public divorce from Charlie Sheen would be punishment enough. And there actually might be a touching story in how, after the recent death of her mother from cancer, her father has moved in with Denise and her two young daughters. We don't see her interact with her daughters much. Instead, she appears to be obsessed with getting one of her two pet pigs pregnant. "She'd be an amazing mom," she confides to the camera. And thus begins a telephonic quest for choice pig sperm.

Now getting on the phone in front of cameras to ask for pig sperm is a weird thing to do, when the whole point of the show is to clear up the "misconceptions" about her past, including the claim that she e-mailed her ex, asking for his sperm. But it's a major plot point. That and the requisite set-up date with a gay guy.

But the date, who does not measure up to the kinds of guys she likes (the aforementioned "bad boys with dark hair and big dicks), allows us to watch her preparing, by getting in the bath -- a creepy scene that reeks of desperation. When her "tanning specialist" comes over to spray paint her nude body in the shower, it's just Girls Gone Tiled.

Really, without all the bathing and pig shit, there's nothing much to write about -- except that in the best Hollywood tradition, her assistant has an assistant. The assistant to the assistant's job pretty much involves picking up pig shit. Really, in a world gone mad, why spoon-feed us such easy metaphors?

There are so many layers of duplicity in Living Lohan that it's far more of a mindblower. I knew about Dina's completely deluded attempt to be the "white Oprah," the partying with Lindsay, etc., which Tracy Ullman captured perfectly in her parody. But until I saw Living Lohan, I had no idea how tough and paranoid she could be. In the show, she comes off as part Tony Soprano in an embellished hoodie and part Richard Nixon with a big French manicure.



Making Mommy Dearest Look Good

A pair of celeb-reality shows takes motherhood to new lows

June 4, 2008

-By Barbara Lippert


adweek/photos/stylus/28217-DeniseRichardsL.jpg

Is Denise Richards 'keeping it real' on her new E! series?

CLICK HERE FOR BARBARA LIPPERT'S PODCAST.

One's an unstoppable momager, traversing Long Island in her custom-upholstered Range Rover, always on the phone. The other's obsessed with pigs and big "dicks," as she says several times on camera, while talking about the loves of her life.

OK, so it's no revelation that the ever-growing "celeb-reality" genre is proof that the end of days is upon us. Granted, the shows are lower than low, but at least the cheesy B- and D-listers who've starred in previous versions knew they were out of career options and chose the nasty self-sploitation instead.

Whereas what's maddening about Living Lohan and Denise Richards: It's Complicated, two shows launched recently as part of E's "Summer Funplex," is that both Mama Bear Dina and farm girl Denise claim they are participating to disprove the tabloids that continue to "trash" them and prove that their lives are, as Richards puts it, "all about family." And as Dina Lohan says, "I want people to know we're, like, normal."

And with that, these two cable programs establish that the new definition of insanity is doing a reality show to prove just how "like, normal" you are. The Lohan show is totally odious, in a depths of hell way that would suggest Dina's head might explode while she becomes possessed with the voice of Hulk Hogan. On the other hand, poor Denise Richards' show is not so much odious as odoriferous -- there's no poop at all, in the celebrity sense, just in the actual pig droppings sense, and there's a ton of that.

Before I saw her show, I actually felt sorry for her. You'd think being married to and then going through a public divorce from Charlie Sheen would be punishment enough. And there actually might be a touching story in how, after the recent death of her mother from cancer, her father has moved in with Denise and her two young daughters. We don't see her interact with her daughters much. Instead, she appears to be obsessed with getting one of her two pet pigs pregnant. "She'd be an amazing mom," she confides to the camera. And thus begins a telephonic quest for choice pig sperm.

Now getting on the phone in front of cameras to ask for pig sperm is a weird thing to do, when the whole point of the show is to clear up the "misconceptions" about her past, including the claim that she e-mailed her ex, asking for his sperm. But it's a major plot point. That and the requisite set-up date with a gay guy.

But the date, who does not measure up to the kinds of guys she likes (the aforementioned "bad boys with dark hair and big dicks), allows us to watch her preparing, by getting in the bath -- a creepy scene that reeks of desperation. When her "tanning specialist" comes over to spray paint her nude body in the shower, it's just Girls Gone Tiled.

Really, without all the bathing and pig shit, there's nothing much to write about -- except that in the best Hollywood tradition, her assistant has an assistant. The assistant to the assistant's job pretty much involves picking up pig shit. Really, in a world gone mad, why spoon-feed us such easy metaphors?

There are so many layers of duplicity in Living Lohan that it's far more of a mindblower. I knew about Dina's completely deluded attempt to be the "white Oprah," the partying with Lindsay, etc., which Tracy Ullman captured perfectly in her parody. But until I saw Living Lohan, I had no idea how tough and paranoid she could be. In the show, she comes off as part Tony Soprano in an embellished hoodie and part Richard Nixon with a big French manicure.



Apparently, she starts every day in the same Nixonian way: combing through the tabloids looking for "lies" about Lindsay. So if the point is that we won't have Lindsay to kick around any more, why is the show based on launching her younger daughter Ali's career as a "recording artist?" I could see if music just flowed out of the kid and she already spent her days writing, composing and playing her own songs that she might want to continue. But Ali seems to be as talented as your average 14-year-old who sings to her iPod. Does the world really need another entirely manufactured adolescent voice and persona? Or is the concept to pit the Spears and Lohan families in a death match to see which pair of sisters can be ruined faster?

Here's where Living Lohan pulls off the triple axel of deception: Ali's "recording contract" is with the Maloofs, who happen to be executive producers of the show and are obviously using it -- way beyond product placement -- to promote their various hotels and recording studios in Las Vegas.

But first the 14-year-old, who is made up to look 25, has to find the right song, and mom uses her camera time to prove how much she cares about her child as an artist. "I will not jam a bad record down her throat. She doesn't want to sing just for the sake of doing a song," she says, impersonating Mother Teresa.

But no matter how cynical you get, you just can't keep up when it comes to Mama Lohan's outrage at a Web site showing what she claims is a faked photo of Lindsay involved in a sex act. "Ali and Cody have to go to school every day and face their schoolmates," she says. (Cody is the 11-year-old son who comes in and out wearing various sports garb; he did some modeling as a little kid, but these days, lucky for him, seems totally neglected.)

But perhaps the most painful moment in the Land of Total Denial is when Ali faces the camera and explains, "Lindsay is my total role model."

This is worse than dumb. In getting her dream, her own reality show, Mrs. Lohan sees herself as a "lioness protecting her cubs." But according to this "reality," she's less lion and more madam. And, I'm sorry to break her bubble, but pimping out her daughter like this for the sake of her dream of "being the white Oprah" is worse than distasteful. It borders on abuse.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author:
* Comment:
 

Other Critiques By Barbara Lippert

Manscaping Monologues

September 29, 2008

Was it only three years ago that the chest-waxing scene in The 40 Year Old Virgin caused such a ruckus? Well, manscaping time must be like dog years: We have come so far in the mainstreaming of male hair removal since then that a chest wax is no longer shocking or wince-worthy. It just seems normal -- like shaving your head. Read Full Article



Our ProductsOur Products

ADWEEK'S CREATIVE NEWSLETTER

A new newsletter every Tuesday and Thursday focusing on the creative community: New campaigns, personnel moves, and much more.

SUBSCRIBE

Stay connected to what's happening in the advertising industry with delivery of the print edition and complete online access.

More VideosVideo

Bud Light gives man the ability to breath fire with disatrous results.; bud light; DDB; fire; A man finds a car grille under his sheets.; Venables Bell; audi; godfather; super bowl; People nod off before being revived by having a Diet Pepsi Max.; BBDO; Chris Kattan; Diet Pepsi; Salesmen must double his sales so turns to salesgenie.com; Indian; mint; salesgenie; super bowl 2008; Men find ways to entertain themselves at a wine and cheese party.; bud light; cheese; DDB; super bowl; wine; Athletes undergo intense training before getting new shoe.; Eric Ogbogu; new prototype; under armour; Animals and people scream as a car almost hits a squirrel.; bridgestone; richards group; scream; squirrel; Kina sings "Message from Your Heart" as part of Doritos "Crash the Super Bowl" promotion.; doritos; Goodby; kina; super bowl 2008; People leave Prudential footprints in their wake.; footprints; insurance; prudential; Video player for AW Creative index and related pages. http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid1329217856http://www.brightcove.com/channel.jsp?channel=1126101268


From print to online advertising trends, advertising professionals can read all about the latest advertising news at Adweek. Keep on top of the latest happenings in the advertising world, from online video advertising to the latest funny TV commercials. Check out our community and advertiser forums to discover and network with other advertiser and marketing professionals. Adweek provides advertisers with daily TV news and weekly ad industry editorials on a complete array of subjects. Use our advertising agency directory to find a career opportunity or to research an ad agency to fit your companies advertising and marketing needs. Explore Adweek everyday, or sign up for our Adverting Newsletter to get the latest ad industry news on demand!

Adweek Advertising Home | Advertising Industry News | Creative TV Advertising | Advertising Industry Community | Video Advertising | Advertising Data Center | Advertising Special Reports | Advertising Careers | Advertising Products | Advertising About Us | Advertising Business Statements | Advertising Contact Us | Advertising Opportunities | Ad Licensing | Advertiser FAQ | Advertising Magazine Subscriptions | Advertising News RSS | Online Ad Site Map | Mobile

© 2008 Nielsen Business Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Terms of Use  |   Privacy Policy