|
Creative > Critique By Barbara Lippert
Page 1 of 2 Tampax, Serena Hit Winning VolleyTennis star's bouts with Mother Nature constitute a 'breakthrough'
Oct 5, 2009
Even worse, print ads created by Leo Burnett showing Serena on court, actively whacking tennis balls at a prim Mother Nature -- on hand to offer the player a "monthly gift" -- were already appearing in September issues of magazines such as Teen Vogue. But P&G has stood by her, and I think it's a wise move. Let's put this in context. The outburst happened on the tennis court, during a critical point that she ended up losing. It's not like Williams was driving drunk or walking around a club with an unlicensed gun in her pants. On the great scale of celebrity embarrassments, it's about a three or four. (David Letterman is about a nine, but he handled it well, with humor and truth.) And given the relentless maw of the 24-hour news cycle, Serena's miscue was forgotten pretty quickly. On the plus side for the brand, the work constitutes a breakthrough, both in terms of diversity and the fact that a serious athlete would be associated with the product. I like the tone of the campaign -- props to Leo Burnett and P&G for being direct and unembarrassed about a subject that has often been taboo. And let's face it, for most girls, after a while, getting a period becomes a hassle, a mess and an embarrassment. I'll never forget my health teacher in sixth grade (a guy with a pocket protector) talking about "commencing the menses," which he pronounced like "census." The girls were mortified. Kudos for personifying Mother Nature as a happenin', modern gal in a tailored, Chanel-like suit and slingbacks. It's much cleverer than the usual gunnysack and wheat-in-her-hair approach. Dressed as a professional woman, she's someone to take seriously; she just happens to hold a red-ribboned gift box instead of an attache case. The casting of Ms. Nature is delightful -- she's Catherine Lloyd Burns, a great comic actress, and in pre-Serena executions of the campaign she'd ambush various unsuspecting young women, like one on the beach in a tiny white bikini. Girls do develop a strong brand preference in this category, and using a stylish Mo Nature is a cute way to get attention. The message is that Tampax Pearl has special LeakGuard Protection, for those particularly worrisome moments. Specifically, the Serena print ad makes the claim that Tampax Pearl "stops leaks better than Playtex Sport." A free sample is offered online. I like the color-block look of the ad -- green suit, red gift, yellow tennis ball, Serena in whites. The way the copy lines are stripped into the bottom of the page actually reminds me of old Virginia Slim ads ("You've come along way baby...") Of course, VS was a longtime sponsor of women's tennis. When Tambrands, (the name of the company before P&G acquired it in 1997) tried to sponsor a Women's Tennis Association Tour in 1995, the offer -- more than $10 million -- was rejected. At that point, the idea of smoking was seen as less offensive and damaging to the sport than the reality that women bleed, I guess. We have come a long way, and that's made clear in the online video, which shows Serena and Mother Nature duking it out at competing press conferences, where Mother Nature actually talks about "bad blood." 1 |2NEXT PAGE »
Tampax, Serena Hit Winning VolleyTennis star's bouts with Mother Nature constitute a 'breakthrough'Oct 5, 2009
Even worse, print ads created by Leo Burnett showing Serena on court, actively whacking tennis balls at a prim Mother Nature -- on hand to offer the player a "monthly gift" -- were already appearing in September issues of magazines such as Teen Vogue. But P&G has stood by her, and I think it's a wise move. Let's put this in context. The outburst happened on the tennis court, during a critical point that she ended up losing. It's not like Williams was driving drunk or walking around a club with an unlicensed gun in her pants. On the great scale of celebrity embarrassments, it's about a three or four. (David Letterman is about a nine, but he handled it well, with humor and truth.) And given the relentless maw of the 24-hour news cycle, Serena's miscue was forgotten pretty quickly. On the plus side for the brand, the work constitutes a breakthrough, both in terms of diversity and the fact that a serious athlete would be associated with the product. I like the tone of the campaign -- props to Leo Burnett and P&G for being direct and unembarrassed about a subject that has often been taboo. And let's face it, for most girls, after a while, getting a period becomes a hassle, a mess and an embarrassment. I'll never forget my health teacher in sixth grade (a guy with a pocket protector) talking about "commencing the menses," which he pronounced like "census." The girls were mortified. Kudos for personifying Mother Nature as a happenin', modern gal in a tailored, Chanel-like suit and slingbacks. It's much cleverer than the usual gunnysack and wheat-in-her-hair approach. Dressed as a professional woman, she's someone to take seriously; she just happens to hold a red-ribboned gift box instead of an attache case. The casting of Ms. Nature is delightful -- she's Catherine Lloyd Burns, a great comic actress, and in pre-Serena executions of the campaign she'd ambush various unsuspecting young women, like one on the beach in a tiny white bikini. Girls do develop a strong brand preference in this category, and using a stylish Mo Nature is a cute way to get attention. The message is that Tampax Pearl has special LeakGuard Protection, for those particularly worrisome moments. Specifically, the Serena print ad makes the claim that Tampax Pearl "stops leaks better than Playtex Sport." A free sample is offered online. I like the color-block look of the ad -- green suit, red gift, yellow tennis ball, Serena in whites. The way the copy lines are stripped into the bottom of the page actually reminds me of old Virginia Slim ads ("You've come along way baby...") Of course, VS was a longtime sponsor of women's tennis. When Tambrands, (the name of the company before P&G acquired it in 1997) tried to sponsor a Women's Tennis Association Tour in 1995, the offer -- more than $10 million -- was rejected. At that point, the idea of smoking was seen as less offensive and damaging to the sport than the reality that women bleed, I guess. We have come a long way, and that's made clear in the online video, which shows Serena and Mother Nature duking it out at competing press conferences, where Mother Nature actually talks about "bad blood." "Did she show you her muscles," Mo asks the crowd. "That's what she always does!" Serena counters with, "I'm not afraid of her -- she's like five foot nothing!" The banter feels a bit forced, I must confess, but what's really funny is the footage of Ms. Nature approaching Serena on the court. The No.2 ranked player keeps hitting her -- hard -- with balls. And Mother Nature, in her heels, tries to avoid the blows, but lets out little yelps that make it sound like she's really getting hurt. The press conference ends with the Mother of us all saying: "Serena loves me like an aunt. Aunt Flo! No really, we're very close!" In truth, menstruation is not for the faint of heart -- and a spitfire like Serena brings new strength to the category.
Other Critiques By Barbara Lippert
|
ADVERTISEMENT ADVERTISEMENT |
|||||||||||




Share on LinkedIn






