Community > Columns > Mark Wnek
SaveE-mailPrintMost PopularRSSReprints

The In and Out of Yes and No

There's more than meets the eye to making a choice -- even for a client

Mark Wnek, Lowe N.Y. CCO

Sept 22, 2008

-By Mark Wnek


Pitching. You love it, you hate it. Depending on whether you win or lose. We just lost one where we left every single thing we had -- every nerve, every sinew, every synapse -- in the room only to be told thanks, but no thanks. It's easy at these times to go down the road of the spurned boy- or girlfriend muttering, "He/she had big ears anyway and smelled funny." But let's face it, when you have loved and lost there's no getting away from the hurt.

What's even harder, at least for the first month, is to see it from the client's point of view -- even if they're as charming and talented a bunch as the group who just told us to go take a hike. Particularly when you have an idea you truly believe to be utterly brilliant and right and game-changing as we did and still do.

But choosing anything is difficult and I'm not sure I'd be great at it. (In fact, my whole life is on many levels a story of often being pretty terrible at choosing right.)

Take the simplest thing: an outfit for an important event. It's an event where you have to make a brilliant first impression; often that's the only impression that will count or that anyone will remember you by. This is not unlike launching or relaunching a brand, when you think about it. So you're trying to buy this outfit and you pass some stores and see something that catches your eye. It seems perfect. You go in, you pick it up. Fabulous. You hold it against yourself in the mirror. Perfect. You envision yourself in the outfit as it brings out all that is best about you. While it's spectacular, it's not an outfit that doesn't fit your character. No, it's an extension of the best part of your character: it shows off your skin, the color of your eyes, your musculature, too. Perfection. At this moment you are at the most emotional and, I would argue, most important point of your decision-making process. You are feeling not thinking, and in doing so you are precisely replicating what the people who you want to wow at the upcoming event will be doing. You have not yet allowed yourself to be gripped by the complacency of common sense. But that is what will of course happen next.

As you hold the outfit you become aware of the fabric and wonder how hard-wearing it is. Will you be able to wear it more than once? You look at the label: a mixture of natural fibers and synthetics. You also notice that it's made in Taiwan. (Good? Bad? Not sure it's good.) Then you notice the price: pretty steep for something that is not all-natural fibers. And the brand: It's one you've heard of. Up-and-coming, maybe? Not Armani or Prada, though... You hold it up again. It does look amazing. You put it down and decide to walk around the store and look at other things. You try Armani and Prada. You look at some sleek, sober, unspectacular items, black mostly. OK, so you might not wow people, but you won't look out of place. You go to the Dolce & Gabbana section. You see some crazy far-out stuff, which is not you at all—but so what? Maybe that could be a good thing? The new you. But will you have the confidence to carry it off? Or will the cognitive dissonance backfire and make you look a bit foolish? Suddenly, in a panic you rush back to the very first outfit you loved. It's still there, thank goodness. You try it on this time. It's even better than you could have expected. You notice people giving you admiring sneak peeks. What is stopping you from going with how you feel and buying it right now? A sales assistant stops by, doing what a sales assistant does: selling. "Has sir/madam looked at the new Armani collection?" What do they mean? Don't they like this? You spot a friend -- thank goodness! You call him over. He has another friend with him. They like it. The friend's friend asks if you've tried the new Armani collection. You could throttle him! Is there a tacit message being communicated about the fact that this outfit is actually unsuitable? If only you were strong enough to just trust your own feelings.

And all we're talking about is buying an outfit. Not a multi-million dollar communications campaign.

So spare a thought for the poor client who has so many factors and sensible strategic and data-driven issues crowding in on their ability to make a decision. Even one you might naively believe should be entirely about how it makes you feel when you first see it.

Mark Wnek is New York chairman and chief creative officer at Lowe. He can be reached at Mark.Wnek@loweworldwide.com.

The In and Out of Yes and No

There's more than meets the eye to making a choice -- even for a client

Sept 22, 2008

-By Mark Wnek


Pitching. You love it, you hate it. Depending on whether you win or lose. We just lost one where we left every single thing we had -- every nerve, every sinew, every synapse -- in the room only to be told thanks, but no thanks. It's easy at these times to go down the road of the spurned boy- or girlfriend muttering, "He/she had big ears anyway and smelled funny." But let's face it, when you have loved and lost there's no getting away from the hurt.

What's even harder, at least for the first month, is to see it from the client's point of view -- even if they're as charming and talented a bunch as the group who just told us to go take a hike. Particularly when you have an idea you truly believe to be utterly brilliant and right and game-changing as we did and still do.

But choosing anything is difficult and I'm not sure I'd be great at it. (In fact, my whole life is on many levels a story of often being pretty terrible at choosing right.)

Take the simplest thing: an outfit for an important event. It's an event where you have to make a brilliant first impression; often that's the only impression that will count or that anyone will remember you by. This is not unlike launching or relaunching a brand, when you think about it. So you're trying to buy this outfit and you pass some stores and see something that catches your eye. It seems perfect. You go in, you pick it up. Fabulous. You hold it against yourself in the mirror. Perfect. You envision yourself in the outfit as it brings out all that is best about you. While it's spectacular, it's not an outfit that doesn't fit your character. No, it's an extension of the best part of your character: it shows off your skin, the color of your eyes, your musculature, too. Perfection. At this moment you are at the most emotional and, I would argue, most important point of your decision-making process. You are feeling not thinking, and in doing so you are precisely replicating what the people who you want to wow at the upcoming event will be doing. You have not yet allowed yourself to be gripped by the complacency of common sense. But that is what will of course happen next.

As you hold the outfit you become aware of the fabric and wonder how hard-wearing it is. Will you be able to wear it more than once? You look at the label: a mixture of natural fibers and synthetics. You also notice that it's made in Taiwan. (Good? Bad? Not sure it's good.) Then you notice the price: pretty steep for something that is not all-natural fibers. And the brand: It's one you've heard of. Up-and-coming, maybe? Not Armani or Prada, though... You hold it up again. It does look amazing. You put it down and decide to walk around the store and look at other things. You try Armani and Prada. You look at some sleek, sober, unspectacular items, black mostly. OK, so you might not wow people, but you won't look out of place. You go to the Dolce & Gabbana section. You see some crazy far-out stuff, which is not you at all—but so what? Maybe that could be a good thing? The new you. But will you have the confidence to carry it off? Or will the cognitive dissonance backfire and make you look a bit foolish? Suddenly, in a panic you rush back to the very first outfit you loved. It's still there, thank goodness. You try it on this time. It's even better than you could have expected. You notice people giving you admiring sneak peeks. What is stopping you from going with how you feel and buying it right now? A sales assistant stops by, doing what a sales assistant does: selling. "Has sir/madam looked at the new Armani collection?" What do they mean? Don't they like this? You spot a friend -- thank goodness! You call him over. He has another friend with him. They like it. The friend's friend asks if you've tried the new Armani collection. You could throttle him! Is there a tacit message being communicated about the fact that this outfit is actually unsuitable? If only you were strong enough to just trust your own feelings.

And all we're talking about is buying an outfit. Not a multi-million dollar communications campaign.

So spare a thought for the poor client who has so many factors and sensible strategic and data-driven issues crowding in on their ability to make a decision. Even one you might naively believe should be entirely about how it makes you feel when you first see it.

Mark Wnek is New York chairman and chief creative officer at Lowe. He can be reached at Mark.Wnek@loweworldwide.com.
Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Author:
* Comment:
 
The opinions expressed in comments are those of the individual poster. They do not necessarily reflect the views of Adweek or Nielsen Business Media. Attacks of a personal nature and comments that are otherwise inappropriate may be removed.

Other Columns by Mark Wnek

The New Age of Wisdom

December 08, 2008

Data rock. They're the floorboards I walk on, the headlights that guide me in the dark, the fishing guides who tell me which fish are where, when and what they like to eat. Without data you're just casting your line out into open water and crossing your fingers. Read Full Article



Our ProductsOur Products

ADWEEK'S CREATIVE NEWSLETTER

A weekly newsletter focusing on the creative community: New campaigns, personnel moves and much more.

SUBSCRIBE

Stay connected to what's happening in the advertising industry with delivery of the print edition and complete online access.

More VideosVideo

Check out the cool video; Amanpour; Eraq; Homer Simpson; Video player for AW Community index and related pages. http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid1329255401http://www.brightcove.com/channel.jsp?channel=1126101268




Adweek Advertising Home | Advertising Industry News | Creative TV Advertising | Advertising Industry Community | Video Advertising | Advertising Data Center | Advertising Special Reports | Advertising Careers | Advertising Products | Advertising About Us | Advertising Business Statements | Advertising Contact Us | Advertising Opportunities | Ad Licensing | Advertiser FAQ | Advertising Magazine Subscriptions | Subscriber FAQs | Advertising News RSS | Online Ad Site Map | Mobile

© 2009 Nielsen Business Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Terms of Use  |   Privacy Policy